For years, American Idol fans have debated one big question: Should contestants perform original songs at auditions? Some viewers see it as brave. Others think it’s risky. But what many really wanted to know was how the judges—especially Carrie Underwood—felt about it.
Now, Underwood has finally given an honest answer, and it’s changing the conversation.
As a former Idol winner who built her own career from the ground up, Underwood understands the pressure contestants feel walking into that audition room. When asked about original songs, she admitted there’s a unique tension in hearing something brand new. Unlike a familiar hit, there’s nothing to compare it to—no expectations, no safety net.
But instead of seeing that as a drawback, Underwood sees it as a powerful opportunity.
According to her, original songs reveal something covers never can: who the artist truly is. The lyrics, the melody, the vulnerability—it all tells a story before the singer even finishes the first chorus. “You learn a lot about someone when they sing something they wrote themselves,” she explained, noting that authenticity often matters more than perfection.
Still, she was clear about one thing: originality alone isn’t enough. Underwood emphasized that the song must connect. If an original track feels genuine and emotionally honest, it can elevate an audition in a way no cover ever could. But if it feels forced or unfinished, it can just as easily work against the singer.
Her perspective surprised fans who assumed judges preferred safe, well-known songs. Instead, Underwood’s response reframed original performances as a bold but deeply revealing choice—one that can instantly set a contestant apart.
In a season where raw storytelling and real emotion continue to resonate with viewers, Underwood’s honesty feels especially timely. It’s a reminder that American Idol isn’t just about hitting the right notes—it’s about discovering artists brave enough to show who they really are.
And sometimes, the most unforgettable performances begin with a song no one has ever heard before.
