As American Idol eyes a milestone 25th season in 2027, attention is turning to its judging panel—especially country superstar Carrie Underwood, who is navigating both on-screen scrutiny and behind-the-scenes frustrations.
ABC has yet to officially confirm the next season, though strong ratings from the current run suggest the show is likely to return. Since its revival on ABC in 2018, the long-running competition continues to rank among the network’s top-rated programs.
Meanwhile, Underwood’s role on the panel has come under the spotlight. Reports indicate she has been frustrated by the way producers highlighted moments when the studio audience booed her, with insiders claiming the edits were exaggerated for dramatic effect. One source revealed producers were “making a mockery” of her by emphasizing the boos.
Despite these tensions, Underwood has remained professional on camera. During Hollywood Week, she addressed negative reactions in real time, acknowledging the audience while delivering her critiques with poise.
Since joining the panel in Season 23 alongside veterans Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie, Underwood’s presence has grown more confident and direct. Season 24 has seen her lean into critiques with greater authority—earning both praise and occasional pushback from fans.
As speculation swirls around the 2027 season, all eyes are on Underwood: Will she return to the judging panel, or is this a turning point for one of American Idol’s most beloved stars?
