When American Idol announced Carrie Underwood as Katy Perry’s replacement at the judges’ table, the choice seemed almost perfect. Underwood rose to fame after winning American Idol in 2005 and has since become one of the most successful and beloved artists in country music history. With her warm personality, relatable charm, and undeniable talent, she appeared to be a natural fit for the long-running competition.
However, recent events may have complicated that picture.
Underwood, now 42, faced backlash after performing at the 2025 inauguration of President Donald Trump, a moment that reignited criticism from fans who strongly oppose the former president. While Underwood has long maintained a largely apolitical public image, the performance reportedly sparked renewed debate — and concern — behind the scenes at American Idol.
Growing Unease Behind the Scenes?
According to Rob Shuter’s Naughty But Nice Substack, some producers may be feeling uneasy about the controversy surrounding Underwood and what insiders describe as her “perceived political alignment.”
One alleged source told Shuter, “Idol is supposed to be feel-good, family-friendly television. The last thing producers want is a judge becoming a political lightning rod.”
Another insider reportedly added, “The show depends on mass appeal. Politics can instantly divide an audience, which goes against what American Idol is built on.”
While none of these claims have been officially confirmed, they suggest that producers may be weighing how much controversy the show — known for its uplifting tone — can afford.
Underwood Keeps Quiet as the Season Moves Forward
For her part, Underwood has largely stayed silent amid the criticism. In the past, she has explained that she avoids political commentary because, as she once put it, “nobody wins.”
Despite the online chatter, there’s little evidence so far that the controversy has affected the show’s success. American Idol Season 24 launched to its strongest premiere in four years, suggesting that viewers are still tuning in — regardless of the debate.
A Career Few Can Match
Controversy aside, Underwood’s credentials are undeniable. According to her official website, she has earned more than 100 major awards, including:
-
8 GRAMMY Awards
-
16 ACM Awards
-
25 CMT Music Awards
-
17 American Music Awards
-
10 People’s Choice Awards
-
7 CMA Awards
Beyond the trophies, Underwood’s versatility has helped define her career. She can move audiences with tender ballads like “See You Again” or deliver fiery empowerment anthems such as “Before He Cheats.” Whether performing spiritual songs or chart-topping hits, her authenticity has remained a hallmark of her success.
What Happens Next?
With American Idol Season 24 still unfolding, it remains to be seen whether the controversy surrounding Underwood will have any lasting impact on her role as a judge. For now, the situation appears more like background noise than a true threat — but in the world of television, perception can matter just as much as performance.
As the season continues, fans and insiders alike will be watching closely to see whether this moment fades away or sparks further change at the American Idol judges’ table.
