Carrie Underwood may be firmly back in her judge’s chair on American Idol, but her return for a second season didn’t happen without careful consideration—and some behind-the-scenes changes.
While viewers see a confident superstar offering advice and encouragement on screen, sources suggest Underwood’s decision to come back was shaped by a challenging first season that pushed her to set firm boundaries before signing on again.
A Tough First Season Behind the Spotlight
According to reports, Underwood struggled more than expected during her initial run as a judge. Between extended time away from her family and intense public scrutiny, the experience proved emotionally demanding.
The backlash she faced—particularly following her decision to perform at President Donald Trump’s 2025 inauguration—was reportedly difficult to navigate. On top of that, constant commentary about her appearance each week added another layer of pressure.
Insiders say the volume of criticism caught her off guard. At one point, there were even conversations about whether she would step away from the show entirely.
The Conditions That Changed the Show
Before agreeing to return, Underwood is said to have made several requests—ones that ultimately influenced the show’s format this season.
One of the most noticeable changes was the removal of Hollywood Week, a long-standing American Idol staple. The adjustment reportedly reduced the amount of time judges needed to film in Los Angeles.
Instead, production shifted more filming to Nashville, a city deeply rooted in music culture and, importantly, closer to Underwood’s home base. The move helped minimize travel and allowed her to balance work and family life more comfortably.
Hawaii, Family, and a New “Ohana Round”
Underwood also reportedly asked for a greater emphasis on filming in Hawaii, leading to the introduction of the new Ohana Round. The addition allowed judges to bring their families along, with filming taking place at Disney’s Aulani Resort.
Sources say this family-friendly environment played a significant role in making Underwood feel supported and grounded while continuing her role on the show.
As one insider explained, many of this season’s changes were designed to accommodate the judges’ needs—particularly Carrie’s.
Why American Idol Made the Adjustments
Despite the challenges, Underwood remains a major asset to the franchise. Her legacy as one of American Idol’s most successful winners gives her a unique connection to contestants—and to viewers.
Behind the scenes, producers reportedly worked to ensure she felt more comfortable, valued, and protected this season. Simply put, they didn’t want to risk losing her.
Where Things Stand Now
Season 24 of American Idol, featuring judges Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan, is currently airing Monday nights on ABC. While the on-screen energy feels familiar, the quieter changes behind the scenes reveal just how much went into securing Underwood’s return.
What viewers see now isn’t just a judge—it’s an artist who came back on her own terms, reshaping the show in subtle but meaningful ways along the way
